Firefly Pizza Grill

Discover delicious, seasoned pizzas at Firefly Pizza Grill in York, PA. Enjoy affordable prices, flavorful subs, crispy bacon, and expertly cooked pies. Call us at +1 717-747-0102 for your next meal!

Welcome to Firefly Pizza Grill

Signature Dining Experience

Firefly Pizza Grill
Firefly Pizza Grill
Firefly Pizza Grill
Firefly Pizza Grill

Step into Firefly Pizza Grill, an inviting pizza haven located at 2509 S George St, York, PA. This pizzeria serves up a delightful selection of Sicilian-style pizzas, mouthwatering subs, and hearty burgers, perfect for any appetite. Whether it's a family outing or a quick meal with friends, Firefly Pizza Grill offers an experience that satisfies both the taste buds and the wallet.

The casual atmosphere complements the welcoming service, making every visit feel like coming home. Firefly stands out in York for its abundance of options, including specialty pizzas that cater to every preference, from meat lovers to vegetarians.

Location & Contact

Address

2509 S George St, York, PA 17403, United States

Phone

+1 717-747-0102

About

Firefly Pizza Grill
Firefly Pizza Grill
Firefly Pizza Grill
Firefly Pizza Grill

Firefly Pizza Grill has established itself as a beloved eatery in York, known for its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. The restaurant prides itself on offering a wide array of dishes that cater to all tastes. With over 147 menu items, including pizza, subs, appetizers, and desserts, diners enjoy a multitude of choices any day of the week. Each menu item reflects a balance of traditional flavors and contemporary twists.

The Sicilian pizza catches attention, served hot from a seasoned oven and prepared fresh daily. Guests rave about the crispy edges and flavorful toppings. The specialty pizzas, like the meat lover's and buffalo chicken, highlight the creative flair of the kitchen. Each sub, whether it’s the veal or the classic cheesesteak, comes piled high with ingredients and often a side of fresh fries. Special lunch combos offer great value during the day.

Firefly Pizza Grill also stands out for its commitment to community. Frequent collaborations with local farms ensure the freshest ingredients, supporting the area’s economy while delivering top-notch food. The restaurant has become a gathering place for friends and families, providing not just meals, but experiences. From celebrating special occasions to casual dinners, Firefly Pizza Grill fuels both appetites and friendships. Regulars and newcomers alike leave with a sense of belonging, making it more than just a dining spot—it's a hub of connection.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday10 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-9 PM
  • Friday10 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday10 AM-10 PM

Firefly Pizza Grill shines with a diverse menu that truly captures the essence of Italian-American cuisine. The signature pizzas feature a beautifully seasoned crust, topped with fresh mozzarella and a variety of toppings to create the perfect pie. For those seeking something different, the Parmigiana subs are a customer favorite, available in classic varieties like meatball, sausage, and breaded chicken. Each bite bursts with flavor, leaving diners craving more.

The inviting ambiance enhances the dining experience. Whether you're in for a quick lunch or a cozy dinner, each meal feels special. Beyond the food, the management places a strong emphasis on community engagement, often hosting local events that draw in neighbors and friends alike. Plus, the reasonable prices allow families to enjoy a night out without breaking the bank. With the busiest times on Fridays, planning ahead ensures a smooth experience.

Firefly Pizza Grill

As you approach Firefly Pizza Grill, the inviting exterior catches your eye with its warm colors and dynamic signage. The outdoor seating allows patrons to enjoy meals al fresco, soaking in the local atmosphere of York. Inside, the vibe is casual and welcoming, with ample seating that caters to families and groups. The cheerful decor reflects the restaurant’s passionate approach to pizza-making and community, providing a comfortable setting to unwind while enjoying a delicious meal.

Customer Reviews

The pizza is DELICIOUS! Definitely 5 star worthy - perfect crust, sauce and ratio of everything including cheese! The owners were very friendly and checked in to make sure we were enjoying our food. We will definitely be repeat customers!

C
Chelsea L.

Their pizza and burger are special it was so good it seems I'm gonna gain punch of weight lol. The service was amazing and lovely people I'll look forward to visit again

A
Akram Z.

YESSSS! We've been looking for a new favorite local pizza spot since John's closed a few years back. Great pizza made by friendly staff that clearly cares about their customers. Will be back soon!

W
William W.

Firefly pizza, formally Vincenco's Pizza, has new ownership. We enjoyed Vincenco's , and now we LOVE FIREFLY. The pizza was cooked to our liking, and the crust was delicious. The new owner is very accommodating. We like our pizza thin and well done, and the owner made it perfection. The Menu offers several specialty pizzas, we are going to try the margaritas pizza next visit.

B
Brian M.

Had an opportunity to visit this restaurant with my family. What a beautiful, cozy establishment! You are immediately greeted with a warm smile, and wonderful soccer memorabilia. We ordered a large cheese pizza with fries. When we received the pizza, it was fresh out of the oven. The pizza was hot, bubbly, and absolutely delicious. Definitely one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. Everything was fresh and the sauce was unique and very tasty. In the past, when I have gone to pizza restaurants, the fries are either hit or miss. They are either very greasy or overly fried. These fries were very tasty. They reminded me of boardwalk fries. And they had a lovely seasoning on them. Every time we went up to the countertop to ask for something, everyone was plugged in and willing to help. I am really happy that we chose to try this establishment, and we will be returning to try a different pizza that was recommended to us. Thank you!

A
Anya C.

Hands down the best pizza in town! The crust is perfect, the toppings are always fresh, and every slice is packed with flavor. On top of that, the customer service is outstanding everyone is warm, attentive, and truly makes you feel welcome. Highly recommend!

M
Mehdi H.